Which banks hold the most deposits in Evansville, IN?
- Deposits in area
- $13.6B
- Institutions
- 15
- Top three share
- 85.0%
- HHI
- 2,977
- Locally based banks
- 5
The Evansville, IN metropolitan area holds $13.6B in bank deposits at 70 branches operated by 15 institutions (FDIC Summary of Deposits, 2026-06-30). Old National Bank is the largest with 44.8%, followed by United Fidelity Bank, fsb at 27.9% and Fifth Third Bank, National Association at 12.2%. The top three together hold 85.0%.
The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index for this area is 2,977, which the DOJ and FTC guideline bands call highly concentrated. That is a snapshot of deposit shares, not a merger-review finding.
5 banks in the catalog take most of their deposits from this area, led by United Fidelity Bank FSB with $5.9B in assets. Of the 1 bank with enough reported ratios for the screen, 0 show no flags, 0 show one flag and 1 shows several. The screen flags equity under 7% of assets, CET1 under 8%, noncurrent loans over 2% of loans, or a negative return on assets. It is a first look from reported ratios, not a rating or a safety judgment.
| # | Bank | City | Assets | Deposits | Market share | Screening |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Old National Bank | Evansville, IN | $74.1B | $6.1B | 44.8% | no flags |
| 2 | United Fidelity Bank FSB | Evansville, IN | $5.9B | $3.8B | 27.9% | several flags |
| 3 | Fifth Third Bank NA | Cincinnati, OH | $300.3B | $1.7B | 12.2% | no flags |
| 4 | German American Bank | Jasper, IN | $8.4B | $646M | 4.7% | no flags |
| 5 | First Federal Savings Bank | Evansville, IN | $582M | $402M | 2.9% | not enough data |
| 6 | Banterra Bank | Marion, IL | $3.5B | $283M | 2.1% | one flag |
| 7 | Peoples Trust&Savings Bank | Boonville, IN | $236M | $192M | 1.4% | not enough data |
| 8 | First National Bank of Carmi | Carmi, IL | $639M | $177M | 1.3% | not enough data |
| 9 | LNB Community Bank | Lynnville, IN | $176M | $161M | 1.2% | not enough data |
| 10 | Stock Yards BANK&TRUST Co | Louisville, KY | $10.3B | $61M | 0.4% | no flags |
| 11 | Boonville FSB | Boonville, IN | $75M | $53M | 0.4% | not enough data |
| 12 | Regions Bank | Birmingham, AL | $161.2B | $35M | 0.3% | no flags |
| 13 | Legence Bank | Eldorado, IL | $631M | $20M | 0.1% | not enough data |
| 14 | First Financial Bank NA | Terre Haute, IN | $6.1B | $14M | 0.1% | no flags |
| 15 | Woodforest National Bank | The Woodlands, TX | $9.1B | $7M | 0.1% | no flags |
Most screening flags
Banks that trip the most screen checks. A flag is a reason to look closer, not a verdict.
- United Fidelity Bank FSB Evansville, IN · $5.9B
| # | Bank | City | Assets | Deposits | Screening |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | United Fidelity Bank FSB | Evansville, IN | $5.9B | $5.4B | several flags |
| 2 | First Federal Savings Bank | Evansville, IN | $582M | $473M | not enough data |
| 3 | Peoples Trust&Savings Bank | Boonville, IN | $236M | $195M | not enough data |
| 4 | LNB Community Bank | Lynnville, IN | $176M | $154M | not enough data |
| 5 | Boonville FSB | Boonville, IN | $75M | $55M | not enough data |
Questions answered from the data
Which bank has the most deposits in Evansville, IN?
Old National Bank holds $6.1B in Evansville, IN, a 44.8% share of the area's $13.6B (FDIC Summary of Deposits, 2026-06-30).
How concentrated is banking in Evansville, IN?
The area has 15 banks with deposits, the top three hold 85.0%, and the HHI is 2,977 (highly concentrated).
How much in deposits are held in Evansville, IN?
$13.6B across 70 branches, as of the 2026 Summary of Deposits.
Which banks are based in Evansville, IN?
5 banks in the catalog take most of their deposits here; the largest by assets are United Fidelity Bank FSB ($5.9B), First Federal Savings Bank ($582M), Peoples Trust&Savings Bank ($236M).
Sources: FDIC and FFIEC Call Reports; FDIC Summary of Deposits. Figures are from the Q3 2026 reporting period, updated 2026-09-30. Methodology